Small Businesses That Plan for Disruption Protect Customer Loyalty

Ahead of Small Business Saturday on Nov. 28, a new report from The Hanover examines the factors that most influence small business shoppers’ trust and the events most likely to damage a business’s reputation.
The findings from “The Hanover’s 2026 Small Business Pulse Report: Reputation, Risk and Resilience” underscore the role preparedness, employee safety and risk management play in helping small businesses maintain trust.

2026 National Young Agent of the Year
When asked to rank the events that would be most likely to damage their trust in a small business, respondents most often placed the following among their top three: Serious product safety issues (73%); customer data or privacy breaches (73%); employee safety or workplace treatment (69%).
Respondents also ranked the factors that were most important in earning their trust. Sixty-eight percent ranked reliable products and services in their top three factors. Protecting customer data followed with 62%. Lastly, transparent communication when problems occurred and treating employees fairly were tied third, with 54% of respondents.
Respondents also associated employee safety with a greater likelihood of business success. Ninety-two percent of respondents agree that small businesses that invest in employee safety are more likely to provide reliable service and remain successful over time.
More Industry Trends
“Our research shows 87% of respondents say small businesses are important to their communities and 61% shop at a small business at least once a week,” said Charles (Chip) F. Hamann, president of small commercial at The Hanover. “Small businesses that proactively manage risk can strengthen customer confidence and position themselves to recover more effectively when disruptions occur.”
“An independent agent is well positioned to help business owners navigate evolving risks, strengthen preparedness strategies and identify insurance solutions that support long-term resilience,” Hamann said.
Preparedness and contingency measures also matter when the unexpected happens, because a business that cannot reopen quickly risks losing customers to the competition. As many as 60% of respondents would temporarily shop with a competitor if their preferred small business closed due to an unexpected event, with more than half seeking alternatives within a week, according to the study.
Will Jones is IA editor-in-chief.









