Is Your Agency Culture AI-Ready?

By Zach Santmier

Ten years ago, my biggest concern as an agency owner was autonomous vehicles. I distinctly remember reading an article outlining Ford’s plan to release a fully autonomous fleet of cars in Michigan by 2022. Turns out, I had nothing to be worried about, at least not in that timeframe.

Now, in 2026, I’m reading similar articles with crushing implications for both my employees’ jobs and our business.

I’m the third-generation owner of Trumble Insurance Agency in Hastings, Michigan, an independent agency my grandfather-in-law started 50 years ago. For over half a century, we have built goodwill in the community, a client base loyal to our agency and a team of 30 agents who work hard to carry on the legacy of excellence passed down to us.

2026 National Young Agent of the Year

However, more than clients, reputation or even employees, the past 50 years have produced something I used to think was intangible: culture.

Every insurance agency sells virtually the same products. They all offer “excellent” customer service and they claim to be “there for you” when bad things happen. So, what makes all of our agencies different? What makes us particularly valuable to our clients? What makes people want to do business with your agency as opposed to mine or the other guy’s down the street with the same carriers?

The answer is simple, yet extremely complex: culture.

Culture is the fuel that propels business forward. It’s the glue that holds business together. It is the immune system that accepts what’s life-giving and rejects what could topple the entire organization. Culture is more than the ethos of business. It is the momentum, the standards and the personality of your agency that sets you apart from me and all of our peers.

However, your culture is at risk of being obliterated by artificial intelligence (AI).

Before you jump to the conclusion that I’m anti-AI, the other leaders in my agency and I are always looking for ways to implement technology that increases productivity and efficiency in every area of our business.

A couple of years ago, we came across an amazing AI phone company that would replace the need for a receptionist or a call tree. This AI agent could even collect information for quotes or policy changes, and it was close to making endorsements on its own.

When evaluating this AI tool, we saw the amazing lift in productivity it could provide. It would mean we would have no missed calls or voicemails. However, it violated our culture. One of our core values is “positivity for years.”

When people call in, they feel a lift in their spirit, not because their need was merely addressed, but because of how we addressed it. A quick look at our Google reviews will show that people feel something when they work with our team. With over 1,100 Google reviews, my entire staff has been named multiple times for how they interacted with our clients and left a positive impression.

We determined that replacing these interactions with an AI agent on the front end would undermine what makes us valuable in the marketplace. We did not move forward with that phone system. Instead, we found a system that made documentation easy and let our agents be more present with clients on the phones—reinforcing our culture instead of replacing it.

How would you define your culture? A decade ago, I asked this question to my team, then eight agents. The answers were all over the map. I realized that if I wanted to scale my agency, I needed to systematize the very thing that made us special: our culture.

Now, at 8:55 a.m. every single workday, you can see our culture in action as we recite our Mission Creed out loud and hear a quick two-minute story or lesson about that day’s Trumble 20 standard, a compilation of our agency’s 20 cultural and procedural standards that sits on every person’s desk.

Use AI Without Losing the Human Touch

Every day, our team completes a five-minute training. Every week, everyone has a 15-minute one-on-one meeting with their manager. And every month, we have a half-day dedicated to moving our written 12-month vision forward as a team.

Together, these documents and rhythms have systematized our culture so that as disruption comes, the thing that makes us special is protected and intentionally grown. Our culture is now a guiding beacon that helps us make smart decisions on what tech may help and what tech could hurt.

Before adopting AI tools that could fundamentally change our agencies, we must first define who we are, what is important to us and where we want to go as a business. From this foundation, we can implement AI in our agencies that reinforces our culture instead of replacing it entirely.

And who knows? This fear we have today about AI may just be the next autonomous vehicle scare. Only time will tell, but until it does, let’s all be intentional leaders who define, systematize, protect and grow the cultures that make us valuable in the marketplace. Because your culture is far from artificial.

Zach Santmier is owner and CEO of Trumble Insurance Agency in Hastings, Michigan.