How Independent Agents Can Effectively Leverage Supplemental Benefits

• April 19, 2026

By Steven Wendlandt

When it comes to insurance, clients may not feel a sense of loyalty. They look for the best deal on the coverage they need and hope that the process is not too onerous or the coverage too expensive. Beyond that, they may not even be able to tell one agent apart from another.

This situation is a double whammy for independent agents, who are looking to secure long-term client relationships and to distinguish themselves from the competition. Supplemental benefits can go a long way to reducing client churn and ensuring that the clients who do stay are happy.

Just like a real estate agent who offers staging as part of selling a home, independent agents can create packages of services that better meet clients’ needs. Options could include:

• Wellness programs.
• Accident and critical illness coverage.
• Public workshops.
• Value-added services, like digital portals or custom coverage evaluations.

Agents may choose to offer certain packages to larger clients or make inexpensive programming available to everyone, without having to stretch themselves to the max to achieve their goal.

Here are three advantages of offering supplemental benefits to clients:

1) Enhance clients satisfaction. Satisfied clients are not always easy to distinguish from the unsatisfied ones, but there are certain clues. Unhappy clients tend to either waste more time on minor issues or go to the opposite extreme and disengage entirely.

By comparison, happy clients are more likely to engage when necessary and minimize the complications they create for their agents. These clients are delighted to discover options that they never knew they needed and rapidly integrate the services into their regular planning.

2) Differentiate agents. Clients often see agents as one-in-a-million. If they cannot distinguish between one agent and another, they will likely go to the one that gives them the best price and the least hassle. Since dropping prices can create a race to the bottom that serves no one in the insurance industry, value-added services make the difference.

Something as simple as an online portal that answers questions like, “What is FSA eligible?” can address client concerns and keep them engaging with the site. If they don’t have to go elsewhere, they are less likely to look for better options.

3) Encourage long-term loyalty. Even the happiest clients may not stay for the duration, which emphasizes the importance of building those long-term relationships. An industry survey showed that clients are more likely to leave an insurance agent due to perceived poor customer service. If they had to call repeatedly or wait an excessive amount of time for an issue to be resolved, they were more likely to pursue their insurance options elsewhere.

Increasing the variety of services that an independent agent offers can also help check more of these boxes, especially over time. Having their needs met competently and completely helps clients stay put rather than look for an agent who will.

Client retention in the insurance industry requires a delicate balance of the right services and prices, especially in a competitive market. Independent agents who offer a range of supplemental benefits can help meet clients’ needs over time, improving retention and long-term loyalty.

Steven Wendlandt is founder of Selected Benefits, Inc.

---

 

---